here has been quite a bit of news and excitement about the Prime
Minister's Rural Development Fellows recently appointed by selecting
young professionals from top Professionals Institutions like IITs, IIMs,
TISS and others. It is a welcome idea that large number of
professionals have been attracted to be such Fellows. It is to be seen
if they will deliver what is expected out of them, especially while
working in the districts affected by Left Wing Extremism. I wish them
all success but the History of such ideas and experiments have failed
globally and we should have deeper analysis of them.
The critics of the PMRDFS have already started asking questions as follows:
Year back, there was a radical thinking in the 7th Five year Plan that the key to Rural Development is the Organisation of Rural Poor(ORP) and it was envisaged that Social Animators and Rural Volunteers selected from the rural communities with BAREFOOT skills and understandings in large numbers would transform the Rural Areas and bring in self-managed institutions. Had it been pursued seriously , we won't have faced Left Wing Extremism today not there won;t have been any need of these top notch professionals sponsored by those who believe that development will trickle down from top.
I shall be happy if someone will prove me wrong.
The critics of the PMRDFS have already started asking questions as follows:
- Whether
these Professionals are really motivated to work in LWE Districts or
are attracted by the salaries and perks? How will they reinvigorate the
sagging spirit of the demoralised development administration?
- Whether these Professionals will be exulted assistants to the District Collectors deeply engaged in report writings and analysing statistics or will be courageous enough to be among the tribal communities?
- Whether these professionals will have a human face and an ideological understanding of the structural situation on the ground?
- Whether these young fellows distinguish the difference between the paddy and ragi, between ethnicity and acculturation and between indigenous values and so called modern development?
- What is the commitment of these Professionals? How many of them will remain when chips are down or there is an offer of a better career?
Year back, there was a radical thinking in the 7th Five year Plan that the key to Rural Development is the Organisation of Rural Poor(ORP) and it was envisaged that Social Animators and Rural Volunteers selected from the rural communities with BAREFOOT skills and understandings in large numbers would transform the Rural Areas and bring in self-managed institutions. Had it been pursued seriously , we won't have faced Left Wing Extremism today not there won;t have been any need of these top notch professionals sponsored by those who believe that development will trickle down from top.
I shall be happy if someone will prove me wrong.
Once I asked to Dr. Parsuraman-"Sir I belong to one of the LWE district and SC catagory age is 35,and not fulfilling the criteria of age eligibility for PMDRF.I have years of work experiences in tribal districts of Odisha, I am interested to compete in the selection process please expand the eligibility for SC/ST/OBC upto 35yrs....". After a 5 min discussion he concluded by saying "....I cant do anything,you approach to Mr. Jairam Ramesh." I hope, you can guess the helplessness of myself as a aspirant and another end a policy maker. There is nothing difference. Suffering of the Tribal will be answered in such ways for years......
ReplyDeleteThanks, Dibya. I met some 25 PMRDFs at Bhubaneswar who have been posted to various LWE Districts. I had a very limited interaction with them but very few of them had the understanding of the Tribal Context. I wonder what output they will deliver!
ReplyDelete